TL;DR
Turn the school run and nap time into listening time
- Thousands of audiobooks, podcasts and originals
- Listen on your phone, tablet or Echo — also offline
- Cancel anytime
Retail expert Simon Childs says there is no guarantee that toys discounted before Black Friday will get cheaper in November. Parents weighing an early purchase against waiting should compare the exact product and total price, while considering the risk that a popular toy could sell out.
With Smyths, Sainsbury’s and Tesco offering toy deals ahead of Black Friday, retail expert Simon Childs says shoppers should not assume that waiting until November will make a discounted toy cheaper. For families planning Christmas purchases, the decision is a trade-off between a possible later discount and the chance that a sought-after toy sells out.
Childs, managing director of Childsey and a former senior retail executive at Ryman, told MadeForMums that there is no reliable way to know in advance whether a particular toy will cost less on Black Friday. Prices can change with demand, stock levels and competing retailers’ offers. A product discounted now might return to its regular price; another could be marked down further if sales are slow.
He also cautions against taking an advertised maximum discount as representative of every product in a sale. An offer of “up to 50% off” does not mean every toy is half-price. Shoppers can compare the same item across several retailers and check price-comparison tools or previous listings to understand its recent price. Product numbers matter: similar-looking LEGO sets, dolls and playsets may have different contents or accessories.
The relevant comparison is the amount payable at checkout, not just the headline saving. Delivery fees, loyalty-card conditions and minimum-spend rules can change which offer is best value. The report says supermarkets may price selected toys competitively to attract customers who might also buy groceries, while specialist toy shops such as Smyths may carry a wider range. Neither type of retailer is guaranteed to be cheapest across the board.
Balancing Savings Against Stock
The timing matters because families face two competing risks: paying more than necessary by buying before a later discount, or waiting and finding that a particular present is unavailable. That is especially relevant when a child has asked for a specific toy and suitable substitutes may not be acceptable. The report does not establish that popular toys will sell out; it presents availability as a consideration, not a certainty.
Early promotions can also help households spread Christmas costs across several weeks or months. But buying presents gradually can make it harder to track total spending. A planned budget and a list of intended purchases can help shoppers judge whether a discount is genuinely useful rather than a reason to add unplanned items.
Products Worth Considering
LEGO Boost Creative Toolbox 17101 Fun Robot Building Set and Educational Coding Kit for Kids
LEGO Marvel Iron Man Mark 3 Collector’s Edition Building Set (76344)
LEGO The Legend of Zelda Great Deku Tree 2-in-1 Set
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Why Toy Sales Start Earlier
Retailers are bringing Christmas promotions forward to reach shoppers before the traditional Black Friday period. According to the MadeForMums report, early offers can encourage families to spend part of their festive budget sooner and can help retailers gauge demand for particular toys. Supermarkets may also benefit if customers buying discounted toys add groceries or seasonal goods to their baskets.
The report identifies Smyths and Sainsbury’s sales weeks before Black Friday, with Tesco also offering toy deals. These promotions create more options for comparison, but they do not establish a general pattern that early prices will rise or fall by a set amount. The timing and level of any later discount depend on the product and retailer.
Childs’s advice is to compare like with like, rather than assuming that a similar-looking product is equivalent. Set contents, piece counts and included accessories can differ. A broader choice at a specialist retailer may matter to a shopper who needs a particular model, while a supermarket promotion may suit someone whose priority is the price of a selected item.
““The key is to focus on the price you’ll actually pay, rather than the saving advertised on the label.””
— Simon Childs, quoted by MadeForMums
Prices and Availability Can Change
The report does not provide a price forecast, retailer-by-retailer comparison, or evidence that any named toy will become cheaper on Black Friday. It also does not identify particular products at risk of selling out. Those details remain specific to each item, retailer and point in time, so shoppers need to check current listings and stock themselves.
It is also unclear whether the toys currently discounted will be included in later promotions, whether the same terms will apply, or how much stock retailers will have. A large advertised discount alone does not answer those questions. The report offers consumer guidance rather than a guarantee of the lowest price.
Check Prices Before You Commit
For shoppers deciding what to do now, the report’s practical next step is to check the exact product across retailers and calculate its full checkout price. Anyone considering waiting can revisit listings as Black Friday approaches, while keeping in mind that both prices and availability may change. If the item is a high priority, compare the current offer with its recent price history and consider whether the present deal is acceptable without assuming a later reduction.
Families can also set a Christmas spending limit and track purchases made during early sales. That helps prevent multiple discounts from adding up to more than the intended budget. No single buying date is identified as best for every toy; the decision depends on the item, its current price and how much a shopper values securing it early.
Key Questions
Will Christmas toys be cheaper on Black Friday?
Not necessarily. Childs says there is no guarantee that a toy discounted before Black Friday will fall further in November. Prices depend on demand, stock and retailer competition.
Should I buy a popular toy before Black Friday?
If a particular present is difficult to replace, buying at a price you consider acceptable may reduce the risk of missing it. The report does not confirm that any specific toy will sell out, so check availability at other retailers and consider suitable alternatives before deciding.
How can I tell if a toy deal is good value?
Compare the exact product across retailers, check its recent listed price where possible, and include delivery charges, loyalty offers and minimum-spend conditions in the calculation. Do not assume that an “up to” discount applies equally to every item.
Are supermarkets or toy shops cheaper?
There is no retailer type that is always cheapest. Supermarkets may offer sharp prices on selected toys, while specialist shops may have a broader selection. Compare the same model and its full cost before choosing.
Source: madeformums.com
